The Thom Hartmann Radio Program
Live Chat Room -- Topic-by-topic audio archives -- Audio Archives -- Web Pages -- Articles on Democracy
New Since your Last Visit
 
We The People
Activism Alerts
Articles by Thom
Audio Archives
Bibliography
Biography
Book Reviews
Books by Thom
Bumper Music
Candidates
Chat Emoticons
Chat Room - main
Clips
Cracking the Code
Events
Frames
Interviews
Law
Movies
National show
News
Newsletters
NLP classes
Photos
Stack
Tag, you're it!
Thom's .com site
Transcripts
White Rose
More!
  Links
  Mercury Retrograde

Subscribe to
Thom Hartmann's Free Newsletter on Politics & the Environment
(we respect your privacy and do not sell or share our list)
Email 
First 
Name 
My email program supports HTML 
    Discussion Community    Forums  Hop To Forum Categories  Thom's Radio Program  Hop To Forums  World Affairs & Iraq    Why US casualities are down

Read-Only Read-Only Topic
Go
Find
Notify
Tools
  Login/Join 
Posted
Posted by permission from Dahr Jamail


Ill-Equipped Soldiers Opt for "Search and Avoid"
Inter Press Service
By Dahr Jamail

WATERTOWN, New York, Oct 24 (IPS) - Iraq war veterans now stationed at a base here say that morale among U.S. soldiers in the country is so poor, many are simply parking their Humvees and pretending to be on patrol, a practice dubbed "search and avoid" missions.

Phil Aliff is an active duty soldier with the 10th Mountain Division stationed at Fort Drum in upstate New York. He served nearly one year in Iraq from August 2005 to July 2006, in the areas of Abu Ghraib and Fallujah, both west of Baghdad.

"Morale was incredibly low," said Aliff, adding that he joined the military because he was raised in a poor family by a single mother and had few other prospects. "Most men in my platoon in Iraq were just in from combat tours in Afghanistan."

According to Aliff, their mission was to help the Iraqi Army "stand up" in the Abu Ghraib area of western Baghdad, but in fact his platoon was doing all the fighting without support from the Iraqis they were supposedly preparing to take control of the security situation.

"I never heard of an Iraqi unit that was able to operate on their own," said Aliff, who is now a member of the group Iraq Veterans Against the War (IVAW). "The only reason we were replaced by an Iraqi Army unit was for publicity."

Aliff said he participated in roughly 300 patrols. "We were hit by so many roadside bombs we became incredibly demoralised, so we decided the only way we wouldn't be blown up was to avoid driving around all the time."

"So we would go find an open field and park, and call our base every hour to tell them we were searching for weapons caches in the fields and doing weapons patrols and everything was going fine," he said, adding, "All our enlisted people became very disenchanted with our chain of command."

Aliff, who suffers from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), refused to return to Iraq with his unit, which arrived in Kirkuk two weeks ago. "They've already lost a guy, and they are now fostering the sectarian violence by arming the Sunnis while supporting the Shia politically ... classic divide and conquer."

Aliff told IPS he is set to be discharged by the military next month because they claim his PTSD "is untreatable by their doctors".

According to the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA), the number of Iraq and Afghanistan war veterans seeking treatment for PTSD increased nearly 70 percent in the 12 months ending on Jun. 30.

The nearly 50,000 VA-documented PTSD cases greatly exceed the 30,000 military personnel that the Pentagon officially classifies as wounded in both occupations.

VA records show that mental health has become the second-largest area of illness for which veterans of the ongoing occupations are seeking treatment at VA hospitals and clinics. The total number of mental health cases among war veterans increased by 58 percent; from 63,767 on Jun. 30, 2006, to 100,580 on Jun. 30, 2007, according to the VA.

Other active duty Iraq veterans tell similar stories of disobeying orders so as not to be attacked so frequently.

"We'd go to the end of our patrol route and set up on top of a bridge and use it as an over-watch position," Eli Wright, also an active duty soldier with the 10th Mountain Division, told IPS. "We would just sit with our binoculars and observe rather than sweep. We'd call in radio checks every hour and say we were doing sweeps."

Wright added, "It was a common tactic, a lot of people did that. We'd just hang out, listen to music, smoke cigarettes, and pretend."

The 26-year-old medic complained that his unit did not have any armoured Humvees during his time in Iraq, where he was stationed in Ramadi, capital of the volatile Al Anbar province.

"We put sandbags on the floors of our vehicles, which had canvas doors," said Wright, who was in Iraq from September 2003 until September 2004. "By the end of our tour, we were bolting any metal we could find to our Humvees. Everyone was doing this, and we didn't get armoured Humvees in country until after we left."

Other veterans, like 25-year-old Nathan Lewis, who was in Iraq for the invasion of March 2003 until June of that year while serving in the 214th field artillery brigade, complained of lack of training for what they were ordered to do, in addition to not having armoured Humvees for their travels.

"We never got training for a lot of the work we did," he explained. "We had a white phosphorous mortar round that cooked off in the back of one of our trucks, because we loaded that with some other ammo, and we weren't trained how to do it the right way." The "search and avoid" missions appear to have been commonplace around much of Iraq for years now.

Geoff Millard served nine years in the New York Army National Guard, and was in Iraq from October 2004 until October 2005 working for a general at a Tactical Operation Centre.

Millard, also a member of IVAW, said that part of his duties included reporting "significant actions", or SIGACTS, which is how the U.S. military describes an attack on their forces.

"We had units that never called in SIGACTS," Millard, who monitored highly volatile areas like Baquba, Tikrit and Samarra, told IPS. "When I was there two years ago, there were at least five companies that never had SIGACTS. I think 'search and avoids' have been going on there for a long time."

Millard told IPS "search and avoid" missions continue today across Iraq.

"One of my buddies is in Baghdad right now and we email all the time," he explained, "He just told me that nearly each day they pull into a parking lot, drink soda, and shoot at the cans. They pay Iraqi kids to bring them things and spread the word that they are not doing anything and to please just leave them alone."



E-mail message checked by PC Tools Spyware


"a long habit of not thinking a thing wrong, gives it a superficial appearance of being right, and raises at first a formidable outcry in defense of custom. But the tumult soon subsides. Time makes more converts than reason."
 
Posts: 1944 | Location: Beautiful New Paltz, NY | Registered: 04 July 2006Report This Post
Posted Hide Post
Another reason is they are calling in air strikes.

Air strikes are up in 2007 over 2006 by a factor of four -- 1,140 so far in 2007, 229 in all of 2006. U.S. military steps up war-zone airstrikes.

This means the probability of a residual anger response somewhere down the line. Very possibly what's a lull now could be changing because bombing in a civilian area -- such as the Sadr City slums -- inevitably kills civilians, and with that goes anger responses. Not to mention the violation of international human rights laws of performing air strikes in densely populated areas.

U.N. challenges U.S. on illegal air strikes in Iraq

quote:
The report makes it clear that U.S. air strikes in densely populated civilian areas are violations of international human rights law. A footnote to the section on "MNF military operations and the killing of civilians" explains, "Customary international humanitarian law demands that, as much as possible, military objectives must not be located within areas densely populated by civilians. The presence of individual combatants among a great number of civilians does not alter the civilian character of an area."

UNAMI demands "that all credible allegations of unlawful killings by MNF (Multi National Force) forces be thoroughly, promptly and impartially investigated, and appropriate action taken against military personnel found to have used excessive or indiscriminate force" and adds that, "The initiation of investigation into such incidents, as well as their findings, should be made public."

The UNAMI report provides the following details of 88 Iraqi civilians killed by air strikes, 15 civilians killed "in the context of raid and search operations" by U.S. ground forces and several incidents of torture and extra-judicial execution by members of Iraqi auxiliary forces under overall U.S. command. UNAMI investigated these incidents because a relative, a journalist or a local official brought each one to its attention. Without doubt, the U.S. Department of Defense is aware of many more killings of civilians by air strikes and ground operations, hence UNAMI's urgent demand for full public disclosure and investigation of all such killings.
 
Posts: 3997 | Location: Road Prison 36 | Registered: 05 February 2004Report This Post
Picture of Loganthor
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Why US casualities are down
What???


**** Disclaimer: The information in this weblog is provided "AS IS" with no warranties, and confers no rights. This weblog does not represent the thoughts, intentions, plans or strategies of my owner. It is solely my own personal opinion. Inappropriate comments will be deleted at the authors discretion.***

"I stand or fall on my own words."
 
Posts: 7253 | Location: PORTLAND | Registered: 07 November 2005Report This Post
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Posted 24 October 2007 17:00 Hide Post

quote:
Why US casualities are down

What???


Yes, they are down and the number of American fatalities and wounded is down. Thank God! Why is that? Another reason is the tribal war and ethnic cleansing is working and Shia Sunni mixed communities is gone! Al Queda never was much a threat in Shia Iraq.The other issue is how long can we sustain the surge? Even General Petraius reports the current troop levels are unsustainable


"a long habit of not thinking a thing wrong, gives it a superficial appearance of being right, and raises at first a formidable outcry in defense of custom. But the tumult soon subsides. Time makes more converts than reason."
 
Posts: 1944 | Location: Beautiful New Paltz, NY | Registered: 04 July 2006Report This Post
Picture of meljomur
Posted Hide Post
See, the surge is working.

No, I heard about the increased air strikes too, who are they bombing? Personally, I find the whole dropping bombs on people, a very cowardly way in which to fight a war, especially when your "enemy" doesn't have the same options.
But then I guess it is hardly surprising that this administration would fight a cowardly war.


"Yeehaw" is not a foreign policy!
 
Posts: 875 | Location: The Emerald City | Registered: 02 January 2007Report This Post
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by meljomur:
See, the surge is working.

No, I heard about the increased air strikes too, who are they bombing? Personally, I find the whole dropping bombs on people, a very cowardly way in which to fight a war, especially when your "enemy" doesn't have the same options.
But then I guess it is hardly surprising that this administration would fight a cowardly war.


Much of what we think of as civilization appears cowardly to me.

I actually don't see the human species as a whole as being that brave, or ethical -- either towards each other or the other species it shares the planet with. Running a herd of buffalo off a cliff to get some meat never struck me as a brave way to "hunt," any more than shooting an elk with a high caliber rifle while sitting in a blind.

So why go down into the streets of Sadr City, for instance, and deal with the risk of an occasional sniper when a bomb is more effective?

Air strikes and collateral damage have been the most "antiseptic" means yet of slaughtering fellow humans and getting out of the "delusion of being ethical" dilemma. And it's only natural to bring the antiseptic strategy in now, the "public" is getting uneasy about the troop deaths, dismemberments and other casualty effects as they accumulate. Time to distract, time to foment some other crisis, Turkey invading northern Iraq, an Iran threat that must be agonized over in the press.
 
Posts: 3997 | Location: Road Prison 36 | Registered: 05 February 2004Report This Post
Posted Hide Post
So Melissa, do you consider suicide vests, persons (dead or alive), cars and IEDs as brave?
 
Posts: 7939 | Location: Santa Barbara | Registered: 19 July 2005Report This Post
Picture of Loganthor
Posted Hide Post
Mel must be gearing up for her stay in England. Because I seem to distinctly recall the British calling us Cowards when Andrew Pickens first started using Guerrilla Warfare tactics against the British in the War of Independence. A highly uncivilized form of warfare.


**** Disclaimer: The information in this weblog is provided "AS IS" with no warranties, and confers no rights. This weblog does not represent the thoughts, intentions, plans or strategies of my owner. It is solely my own personal opinion. Inappropriate comments will be deleted at the authors discretion.***

"I stand or fall on my own words."
 
Posts: 7253 | Location: PORTLAND | Registered: 07 November 2005Report This Post
Picture of Chaos-Theory
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by Ronald Rutherford:
So Melissa, do you consider suicide vests, persons (dead or alive), cars and IEDs as brave?



I wouldn't lower myself to judging military tactics as brave or cowardly, much to emotional. How about we place them into different categories for this war, lets try Smart and Stupid.

Smart- IEDs. Taping together some old leftover Soviet era artillery shells, with a disposable cell phone as a remote detonator, is pure genius. Very low cost, kills or maims the enemy, and most of the time the fellow who sets the trap, lives to fight another day.

Stupid- Airstrikes. Using the latest in cutting edge, million dollar, laser guided munitions, to blow up a building in some slum. Where the local fighters had a dozen AK-47s and a few Mortars stashed, is not cost effective. Plus the locals can usually haul out some dead children, helping your enemy in their recruiting efforts.

Smart- Search and Avoid. Rather then give your enemy something to use his IEDs on. You find yourself a nice patch of safety, and play cards or something.


"I have no one to talk to since Mahatma Gandhi died.” Vladimir Putin.
 
Posts: 268 | Location: usa | Registered: 09 July 2001Report This Post
Posted Hide Post
Mahdi army called a cease fire in August http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/3612168.stmas Their army was starting to disintegrate due to all the areas that had been cleansed of Sunnis; Moqtada Sadr is consolidating power. Factions were forming among the Shea so he wanted to make sure he kept control and stayed as their main leader. (Yet another known despot like Saddam that should be in jail but will be a "partner for peace" and will have to be dealt with at some future time, we learn nothing from our history and are doomed to repeat these mistakes.)

Its sad, all the surge troops didn't do a damn thing, but this thug and his merry band of torturers has control and can escalate and deescalate the situation. Of course Bush will claim the surge is working, when A) violence is less during the summer (something about 140 degrees takes the fight out of anyone) B) They reset the bench marks for what constitutes Iraqi death by sectarian violence C) the neighborhoods are less diverse than before; 1 million dead, 2 million refugees outside Iraq and 2 million refugees inside Iraq and since the country had 25 million to start ..well its pretty sad, a lot of blood on our hands.
There are 3 months left of the Mahdi cease fire and with Turkey ready to attack the Kurds in the north, the only stable area of Iraq, the deaths will go up. We need our troops out NOW! And I hope they take the corrupt contractors with them; the blackwaters and halliburton's are doing more harm than good.


In short, you see, the essential is to cease being free and to obey, in repentance, a greater rogue than oneself. When we are all guilty, that will be democracy... Death is solitary, whereas slavery is collective. Albert Camus, The Fall.
 
Posts: 3 | Location: Huntington Beach, CA | Registered: 20 September 2007Report This Post
Posted Hide Post
quote:
2007 is deadliest year for U.S. troops in Iraq

BAGHDAD -- The U.S. military on Tuesday announced the deaths of five more soldiers and one sailor, making 2007 the deadliest year for U.S. troops despite a recent downturn, according to an Associated Press count.

At least 853 American military personnel have died in Iraq so far this year -- the highest annual toll since the war began in March 2003, according to AP figures.

The grim milestone passed despite a sharp drop in U.S. and Iraqi deaths here in recent months, after a 30,000-strong U.S. force buildup. There were 39 deaths in October, compared to 65 in September and 84 in August.

Five U.S. soldiers were killed Monday in two separate roadside bomb attacks, said Rear Adm. Gregory Smith, director of the Multi-National Force-Iraq's communications division.

"We lost five soldiers yesterday in two unfortunate incidents, both involving IEDs," Smith told reporters in Baghdad's heavily-guarded Green Zone. Later, the military said four of the soldiers died after an explosion near their vehicle in Kirkuk province, and one was killed in Anbar.

In a third statement, American forces said a sailor died of injuries from an explosion Monday in Salahuddin province, north of Baghdad.

With nearly two months left in the year, the U.S. toll has already surpassed that of 2004, when 850 troops died ...

http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/200...6/20071106?hub=World



quote:
Accused killer tried to enlist in the military

Accused killer Gregory Allan Despres tried several times to join the Canadian military and the U.S. marines but was never accepted, his grandfather told a Fredericton judge on Tuesday.
http://www.cbc.ca/canada/new-brunswick/story/2007/11/06/despres-day2.html


And in the "Don't think this isn't also happening in the US Military" category:

quote:
Ottawa soldier charged with trafficking pot, hashish

An Ottawa-based soldier has been charged with trafficking pot and hash following an investigation by military police.

The Canadian Forces National Investigation Service said Monday it had charged Master Cpl. Steven Pearson with five counts related to the alleged trafficking and possession of marijuana and hashish.

http://www.cbc.ca/canada/ottawa/story/2007/11/06/ot-soldier-drug-071106.html
 
Posts: 771 | Location: Winnipeg | Registered: 06 September 2001Report This Post
 Previous Topic | Next Topic powered by eve community  

Read-Only Read-Only Topic

    Discussion Community    Forums  Hop To Forum Categories  Thom's Radio Program  Hop To Forums  World Affairs & Iraq    Why US casualities are down

Individuals are legally responsible for their views. Messages or parts of messages may be quoted or read on the radio, or reprinted in Thom's books and other materials.